Risk, diversification and accidental concentration
Why spreading money helps, what it can't do, and how people end up concentrated without noticing.
Two different risks
The risk that one company fails can be diversified away — hold two hundred and any single failure is survivable. The risk that markets as a whole fall cannot be, because everything falls together.
Diversification is therefore very effective against the first and close to useless against the second. Anyone promising protection from both is describing something that doesn't exist.
Concentration arrives by accident
Very few people deliberately put a third of their money into a handful of companies. Plenty end up there, because global index funds weight by company size, and the largest listed companies are currently a small group of US technology firms.
Holding four global funds from four providers can leave you with much the same underlying exposure four times over — which feels diversified and isn't.
Currency is a risk too
A UK investor holding US shares is exposed to the dollar as well as to the companies. The investment can rise in dollars and still be worth less in pounds.
Mia Invest shows totals per currency as well as converted into one. The per-currency figures are exact; the converted one depends on the rate used and the day it was published, so it is a snapshot rather than a fact. Where no rate is available for a currency, its value is left out and said to be left out, rather than quietly folded in.
See it against your own money
Read next
-
Volatility, drawdown and having time
What the swings actually feel like, and why the time you have changes everything.
-
Where beginners most often come unstuck
The recurring, avoidable ones — mostly behavioural rather than analytical.
Terms on this page
- Diversification
-
Spreading money across many investments so no single failure is fatal.
It reduces the damage one company or sector can do. It does not protect against a fall in the whole market, and holding five funds that all track the same index is far less diversification than it looks.
- Concentration
-
How much of a portfolio sits in one holding, sector or country.
The opposite of diversification, and easy to acquire accidentally: several global funds can hold the same handful of large US technology companies.
- Capital at risk
-
You can get back less than you put in.
True of every investment on this site. It is not a formality — it is the defining difference between investing and saving. Nor is it avoidable by choosing something described as safe: holding cash instead removes the price movement and leaves inflation to erode what the money buys. Which risk you are taking changes; whether you are taking one does not.