ISAs, SIPPs and general accounts
The same investment can be taxed very differently depending on where you hold it.
A wrapper is not an investment
An ISA isn't a thing you invest in — it's a container that changes the tax treatment of whatever you put inside it. The same fund can sit in an ISA, a SIPP or a general account and behave identically apart from tax.
Beginners often ask which is 'better'. They do different jobs, and the honest answer depends on when the money is needed and what tax you'd otherwise pay.
The three common containers
A Stocks and Shares ISA: growth and income are free of UK tax, with an annual contribution limit, and you can take money out whenever you like.
A SIPP: contributions attract tax relief, which is a substantial boost going in, but the money is locked away until the minimum pension age and is largely taxable coming out.
A general account: no wrapper, no limits, and gains and income may be taxable.
Where it starts to matter
Inside an ISA or SIPP, the distinction between income and capital gains is irrelevant — neither is taxed. In a general account it matters a great deal, because they're taxed under different rules at different rates with different allowances.
One UK quirk worth knowing: capital gains on gilts are exempt from capital gains tax for individuals, while their coupons are taxed as income. That makes the split between the two a real consideration outside a wrapper.
The quirk belongs to individuals only. A company holding the same gilt gets no exemption — company debt holdings sit under the loan relationships rules, which treat the entire return, coupon and capital movement alike, as income for corporation tax. Where an investment is held can matter as much as which investment it is.
This is not tax advice
Allowances, rates and limits change, and how they apply depends on your total income and circumstances. Everything above describes how the containers work in general terms.
For anything that turns on your own numbers, a qualified accountant or tax adviser is the right person to ask.
See it against your own money
Read next
-
Income or growth: Acc and Inc share classes
Two versions of the same fund, differing only in what happens to the income.
-
Bonds: price, coupon and yield
Why a bond paying 5% can earn you more or less than 5%.
Terms on this page
- ISA
-
A UK tax wrapper. Growth and income inside it are free of UK tax.
Stocks and Shares ISAs hold investments. There's an annual contribution limit. The wrapper doesn't change what you own or its risk — only the tax.
- SIPP
-
A personal pension you control. Tax relief going in; locked up until later life.
Contributions attract tax relief, which is a large up-front boost, but the money is inaccessible until the minimum pension age and is taxable on the way out beyond the tax-free portion.
- General account
-
An ordinary dealing account with no tax wrapper.
Also called a GIA or trading account. Gains may be liable to capital gains tax and income to income tax. This is where the coupon-versus-capital distinction on bonds starts to matter.
- Gilt
-
A bond issued by the UK government.
Considered low credit risk in sterling terms. For UK individuals, capital gains on gilts are exempt from capital gains tax, though the coupons are taxed as income — which is what makes the split between the two worth noticing. A company gets no such exemption: gilts fall under the loan relationships rules, and the whole return is taxed as income for corporation tax.